Investigation 2026-05-25: for tenant client1 (tenant_id=2) on prod liderra.ru:
- 205 leads at supplier (info@lkomega.ru, visit=rt) vs 160 deals on portal
- 82 leads lost (76 via 302-redirect from ValidationException, mostly
non-B-prefix projects: client.carmoney.ru, cashmotor.ru, etc.)
- 37 duplicate deals (CSV-recovered SupplierLead vid=null + later
webhook with real vid "create two Deals because supplier_lead_deliveries
locks on supplier_lead_id, not phone+project)
Three independent fixes, three plans, three deploys:
Phase 1 (low risk): Always JSON 422 for webhook ValidationException
Phase 2 (med risk, billing): merge webhook-after-CSV-recovered into
existing deal, no double-charge
Phase 3 (high risk, migration): accept non-B projects as platform=DIRECT
end-to-end (controller + 4 services + migration)
Phase 3 includes new LeadRouter fallback path: DIRECT-supplier_projects
match Liderra projects via signal_type+signal_identifier directly
(no project_supplier_links pivot required, since psl rows don't exist
for auto-created DIRECT supplier_projects).
Refs: docs/superpowers/specs/2026-05-25-supplier-webhook-reliability-design.md
Append-only journal capture during the factor-analysis bug-surface session.
Episodes contain live tests of the LLM classifier retry logic (10/10 LLM
success rate post-retry) and the prefilter Layer 1 gate on short prompts.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Sync шапок и changelog'ов 3 нормативных файлов под Pravila v1.42
(коммит a2d6feb7 §17.7 «Coverage announcement»). Только cross-refs,
без контентных правок § тел.
- CLAUDE.md: §0 row Pravila v1.41→v1.42; §9 +entry «cross-ref update».
- docs/Tooling_v8_3.md: header cross-ref Pravila v1.41+→v1.42+;
§13 footnote «Прил. Н v2.23 от 25.05.2026 cross-ref update».
- docs/Plugin_stack_rules_v1.md: §0 changelog Pravila v1.39+→v1.42+;
История версий +entry v3.22 (cross-ref update).
Tooling канон счётчиков #1-#83 не тронут (Phase 3 deferred — не
плагины, не агенты). Записи v1.34-v1.41 в §10 Pravila таблице
по-прежнему не дотянуты (известный дрейф предыдущих сессий, вне
этого scope).
Через subagent normative-sync (#84) per Pravila §2.4. Гейт
cross-ref-checker (C2): 0 drift.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Closes Phase 3 deferred follow-up #1 from project_brain_overhaul.md.
Адресует «дыру»: enforcement (§17.4) ловит факт нарушения, но без
явной coverage-пометки в ответе невозможно отличить осознанный
выбор канала от молчаливого среза угла.
- §17.7 (new): «coverage: <channel>:<id>» обязательна на non-conversation
задачах. 6 каналов: skill / node / chain / hook / agent / direct.
Observability layer (не enforcement) — фиксирует НАМЕРЕНИЕ.
- Граница с routing-тегом §16.7: routing-тег только для
user_directed_method, coverage-пометка — всегда для non-conversation.
- C5 controller surface отсутствующих пометок в STATUS.md.
- Cross-ref: registry/nodes.yaml, routing-off-phase.md, парсер
schema v4.4+ (deferred #2).
Header bump v1.41 → v1.42 + §10 changelog row v1.42. Записи v1.34-v1.41
в §10 не дотянуты (известный дрейф предыдущих сессий) — шапка
«Что изменилось в v1.NN» авторитетна для этого периода. Нормативный
синк CLAUDE.md/Tooling/PSR_v1 — следующим шагом через normative-sync.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 2 Task 8 of LLM-first router overhaul.
- tools/router-config.mjs: 4 constants (CLASSIFIER_MODEL='claude-sonnet-4-6',
REVIEWER_MODEL='claude-opus-4-7', INHERITANCE_MAX_AGE_MIN=30,
REVIEWER_MAX_NEIGHBOR_EPISODES=10). Sonnet 4.6 ID resolved via ProxyAPI
/v1/models 2026-05-25 — only alias 'claude-sonnet-4-6' is exposed (no dated
YYYYMMDD form on this reseller); alias is canonical here.
- docs/registry/nodes.yaml: capabilities: line added to all 85 nodes
(1-2 sentences describing what each node DOES, not when to choose it —
classifier infers selection from capabilities + user prompt). Generated
by Sonnet subagent from CLAUDE.md §3.x + Tooling §4.X attribute blocks
+ spec §18.3 format. Spot-checked + verified no forbidden 'use when' framing.
- docs/registry/schema.json: +capabilities top-level node property
(type:string minLength:1). G12 'permissive' note in plan was stale —
schema had additionalProperties:false; explicit extension is the
cleanest compliant path.
Verify (plan Step 2): nodes=85 caps=85, exit 0.
Tests: tools/router-config.test.mjs 4/4 PASS + tools/registry-load.test.mjs
11/11 PASS (Ajv schema-validate on amended schema GREEN).
Phase 1 Task 6 of LLM-first router overhaul. Minimal-scope execution after
reality check (C1/C2 controllers don't track section refs, only version
drift; plan steps about §3.3/R15 archiving are out of scope for cross-ref
update).
Changes:
- CLAUDE.md §0 'Источник истины' row for Pravila: **v1.40 от 24.05.2026**
-> **v1.41 от 25.05.2026** + narrative bump (§12 archived in Task 4,
§17 added in Task 5 via ADR-016).
- docs/Tooling_v8_3.md line 4 cross-ref:
cross-ref Pravila v1.39+ -> v1.41+ (+ CLAUDE.md v2.27+ -> v2.28+).
Deferred (TASKLOG.md Task 6 section for full reasoning):
- §12 textual occurrences in PSR_v1 (39) and historical Tooling/CLAUDE.md
changelog blocks remain as honest historical pointers to the archived
§12 (docs/archive/llm-bootstrap-2026-05/pravila-12/...).
- CLAUDE.md §3.3 archive + nodes.yaml pin — out of scope, requires
structural restructure beyond cross-ref work.
- Tooling §4.X 'когда брать' archive — out of scope.
- PSR_v1 R15 — already removed in v2.0 (motion-runtime removal,
12.05.2026); current R15 is 'Off-phase routing', unrelated to §12.
Verification:
- tools/l1-watcher.mjs: OK — 0 drift.
- tools/cross-ref-checker.mjs: OK — 0 drift in 4 files (was FAILing on
Pravila v1.40 / v1.39 references after Task 5 bump to v1.41).
- npx vitest run tools/: 539 passed (unchanged from Task 4 baseline).
Plan: docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-25-llm-first-router-overhaul.md Task 6.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 1 Task 2 of LLM-first router overhaul.
Live user-level changes (NOT in git, see TASKLOG.md for full diff manifest):
- ~/.claude/settings.json — removed 2 PreToolUse blocks:
- matcher 'Skill' -> skill-marker.py (§12 trigger marker)
- matcher 'Edit|Write|MultiEdit' -> skill-check.py (§12 enforcement on Edit)
- Remaining PreToolUse: 1 block (economy-state-guard, pure economy)
- ~/.claude/hooks/economy-mode.py — trailer text:
'§12 hard rule из Pravila НЕ override-ится' -> '§17 universal skill-coverage НЕ override-ится'
- ~/.claude/hooks/economy-state-guard.py — NO-OP (no §12 logic; pure economy)
Economy system (0%/5%/25%/50%/75%/100%) remains fully active. Stop-hook
subagent verifier (model: claude-sonnet-4-6) remains. PostCompact, SessionStart
hooks unchanged.
skill-marker.py and skill-check.py files remain on disk in ~/.claude/hooks/
(snapshot already in docs/archive/.../user-hooks/ from Task 1). They are
unwired from PreToolUse — no longer invoked. Task 4 moves them into the
archive proper.
permissions.ask still references skill-marker.py/skill-check.py (4 entries
Edit/Write each) — these gate direct file edits and are harmless. Cleaned
up alongside Task 4 archive.
Verification:
- ~/.claude/settings.json parses as valid JSON (1 PreToolUse block).
- All 4 economy hooks (economy-mode, economy-state-guard, economy-postcompact,
economy-self-check) still run with exit 0.
- Live economy-mode.py with prompt 'тест экономия 5%' returns valid hook
JSON with FIRST LINE '=== ECONOMY MODE: 5%' and trailer mentioning §17.
Rollback: 'node tools/test-rollback.mjs --execute' restores both files
from snapshot (verified e2e in Task 1).
Plan: docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-25-llm-first-router-overhaul.md Task 2.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Establishes a proven rollback mechanism for the LLM-first router overhaul before
any destructive step. Without this, Phase 1-3 work would be irreversible.
What this commit adds:
- Git tag 'brain-pre-llm-bootstrap' on origin/main 9d4a30c3 (pre-overhaul state).
- docs/archive/llm-bootstrap-2026-05/ archive structure with:
- settings-snapshot/ — pre-overhaul ~/.claude/settings.json + project settings
- user-hooks/ — all 14 ~/.claude/hooks/*.py pre-overhaul (incl. §12 ones)
- runtime-flags-snapshot/ — pre-overhaul ~/.claude/runtime/*-mode.json
- nodes-yaml-archive/ — pre-overhaul docs/registry/nodes.yaml
- tools/test-rollback.mjs — rollback planner + executor (--dry-run / --execute)
- tools/test-rollback.test.mjs — TDD: 3 tests for planRollback() contract
- ROLLBACK.md — operator runbook with from->to manifest
E2E smoke proof was run BEFORE this commit (Task 1 step 9):
1. Created TEMP marker commit on top of tag with a dummy file + runtime flag.
2. Ran 'test-rollback.mjs --dry-run' (OK) then '--execute' (user state restored).
3. Reverted git-tracked state and verified marker + flag gone.
4. Verified Task 1 untracked files survived the rollback.
Smoke discovered a bug in the plan's procedure ('git checkout tag -- .' +
'git reset --soft tag' does NOT delete files committed-after-tag — they stay
staged). ROLLBACK.md uses 'git reset --hard <tag>' instead, which correctly
removes overhaul-added tracked files while preserving untracked artefacts
(episodes-*.jsonl, observer notes).
TDD: 3/3 green on test-rollback.test.mjs. Full vitest tools/: 546 passed (was
543 baseline, +3 from this commit), 4 pre-existing 'No test suite' failures
on tools/ruflo-* and tools/subagent-prompt-prefix.test.mjs (out of scope).
Plan: docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-25-llm-first-router-overhaul.md Task 1.
Spec: docs/superpowers/specs/2026-05-24-llm-first-router-overhaul-design.md.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
EnsureSaasAdmin fail-closed 503 вне dev/testing → вся админка на боевом
liderra.ru недоступна (все /api/admin/* падали). Настоящий saas-admin SSO
(Yandex 360) ещё не готов (Б-1 + DO-4), но держать зону наглухо закрытой
нельзя — заказчику нужна админка.
Стопгэп (выбор заказчика): защита /admin + /api/admin/* переносится на
nginx (отдельный HTTP Basic Auth, /etc/nginx/.htpasswd-admin), middleware
зону больше не закрывает. Тест production-кейса переведён с 503 на 200.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
v2.0 → v2.1 — 3 группы изменений (16 пунктов суммарно):
Группа 1 — решения принятые после v2.0, не внесённые:
- 1.1 Памятка classifier (4 паттерна: brainstorming / discovery-interview /
writing-plans / systematic-debugging). +flag prompt-enrichment-mode.
- 1.2 Reviewer как полноценный Claude Code subagent (tools=[Read,Grep,Glob,
Skill], model=opus). Новый файл .claude/agents/reviewer-agent.md.
+стоимость $240-1200/мес vs $40-80 direct API. Crash fallback на direct
API. Context bloat cap 10 соседних эпизодов.
- 1.3 Inheritance + 3 группы коротких prompt'ов (continuation/acknowledgment/
cancellation) + 30-минутный таймаут. +flag inheritance-mode. Новые поля
в schema v4.1: inherited_from_task_id, inheritance_age_minutes,
previous_direction_rejected, previous_task_id_rejected.
Группа 2 — edge cases:
- 2.1 Reviewer model явно opus в agent file.
- 2.2 Reviewer subagent crash → fallback direct API call.
- 2.3 Reviewer context bloat: max 10 episodes в agent system prompt.
- 2.4 Manual override приоритет №1 в prefilter (раньше inheritance).
- 2.5 Cancellation clears state + previous_task_id_rejected marker.
Группа 3 — мелкие упущения:
- 3.1 brain-retro SKILL.md description: раз в 1-2 недели (не sprint).
- 3.2 recommended_chain_id nullable для custom chains.
- 3.3 Embedding только для non-prefilter эпизодов.
- 3.4 PII filter wraps sanity-check comments.
- 3.5 requested_node fuzzy matching fallback.
- 3.6 Anchor word list inline initial.
- 3.7 Self-retrospect counter init в фазе 3 step 3.3.
- 3.8 Sanity-check answer file schema_version=1.
Cost rewrite: 720-1380 USD (v2.0) -> 1940-8200 USD (v2.1) на 6 месяцев
из-за reviewer subagent. Granular rollback через reviewer-mode=direct-api
возвращает к v2.0 ценам.
§21 новый — changelog v2.0 → v2.1 со всеми 16 пунктами и где правка.
Реализация — после закрытия Биллинга v2 Спек C.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
readRouterState(sessionId, {baseDir}) -- pure read state-файла сторожа.
extractRouterFields(state) -- pure извлечение 4 полей для primary_rationale.
Используется парсером эпизодов на следующем шаге (Task 3).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
3-task TDD-ish plan to create two new project agents:
- Task 1: .claude/agents/normative-sync.md (full Sonnet 4.6 system prompt)
- Task 2: .claude/agents/prod-deploy-validator.md (8 SSH checks + quirks 104-108)
- Task 3: First dry-run smoke test for both + capture lessons in memory
Spec: docs/superpowers/specs/2026-05-24-controller-offload-agents-design.md (71a5dd6).
Also: +2 cspell-words (маппинге, dogfooded).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
3 дыры обнаружены при инспекции warn-only состояния сторожа 24.05.2026:
1. UTF-8 mojibake в state-файле сторожа (Windows Node stdin без setEncoding).
2. recommended_node не пишется в эпизоды наблюдателя (helper существует, не подключён).
3. chain_progress / chain_completed / recommended_chain — то же.
Без починки brain-retro новых метрик (domainHitRate / chainCompletionRate)
покажет пустоту, а Layer 2 эскалация на русских промптах работает по
испорченному тексту. Stage 3 enforce включать до фиксов нельзя.
Spec scoped к 3 файлам кода + ≤80 строкам нетто; subagent-driven
последовательно (3 Sonnet + closure Opus). Smoke на живой сессии.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Spec for two specialized AI agents to offload the main controller:
- #1 normative-sync: applies 4-file normative sync (Pravila/PSR/Tooling/CLAUDE.md)
after a completed task. ~20 invocations/week, saves ~70K controller tokens
per episode. Model: Sonnet 4.6.
- #2 prod-deploy-validator: 8-check pre-flight before liderra.ru deploy.
~5-7 invocations/week. Driven by 24.05 03:46 UTC 18-min portal incident
(quirk 107 — config:cache not under www-data). Model: Sonnet 4.6.
Based on brainstorming session 24.05 with measured frequencies from
MEMORY.md + CLAUDE.md §6 + push history 16-24.05.
Precedents: pest-parallel-debugger, rls-reviewer project agents.
Also: +7 cspell-words entries for the new spec.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Pre-sharing-эпик legacy: ProcessWebhookJob + WebhookReceiveController +
POST /api/webhook/{token} + webhook_log/webhook_dedup_keys/tenants.webhook_token.
На проде 0 вызовов за всю историю. Не часть актуальной архитектуры каналов
(основной = шеринг crm.bp-gr.ru, резервный = CSV reconcile — оба уже на always-rub).
Удаление снимает блокер для Phase B Спека A (DROP COLUMN balance_leads),
закрывает публичный endpoint /api/webhook/{token}, убирает расхождение
биллинг-моделей в коде.
Approach: одним PR, одним релизом. Бэкап перед миграцией, 7д наблюдение.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
active-projects.md обновлён: этап 2 ✅ + влит в main, этап 3 ✅ Phase A+B + влит
в main (warn-only режим, никакой блокировки), bug-fix bec69aa5 (deriveRouterStep)
включён. CHECKPOINT B накапливает реальные наблюдения; Task 9 (переключение
в enforce + 2 метрики) — отдельно после ревью baseline.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Эпизоды реальных сессий после hotfix — сторож пишет state + классификацию
на каждый промпт (verified: UUID-session state files). Данные для brain-retro
warn-only ревью.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two real bugs found via verification (hook didn't fire in live session):
1. UserPromptSubmit block had matcher:"*" — event doesn't support matcher,
non-standard block dropped (claude-code-guide authoritative). Removed →
block now {hooks:[...]} like working observer-stop-hook.
2. stdin field was event.user_prompt; Claude Code sends event.prompt.
Now reads (event.prompt || event.user_prompt) for compat.
Field-fix verified manually with real stdin shape {prompt:...} → #71 pdn-152fz.
Firing fix (matcher) NOT verifiable in-session (hooks load at session start) —
needs restart + next-turn state-file check.
NB stop-gate turn_events field also wrong (Stop sends transcript_path) — separate
follow-up, not on observation critical path (affects chain tracking only).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
UserPromptSubmit → router-prehook (classifier).
PreToolUse Edit|Write|MultiEdit|Bash → router-tool-gate (warn-only).
Stop → router-stop-gate (chain progress).
router-gate-mode.json = warn-only (outside repo, ~/.claude/runtime/).
Переключение в enforce — отдельным шагом после Checkpoint B (24ч наблюдения).
End-to-end smoke verified: «проверь пдн» → #71 pdn-152fz-audit,
warn-only пишет в stderr, не блокирует. Доменная разметка Task 1 работает.
NB активация в основной сессии: хуки в worktree-копии settings.json
версионируются; для реального наблюдения нужна либо merge ветки, либо
ручное применение к основному .claude/settings.json (warn-only безопасен).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
После каждого хода обновляет state.chainProgress по реально вызванным
скилам. chainCompleted=true когда последний шаг достигнут.
skillInvokedThisTurn флажок для PreToolUse gate.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Подкрутка classifier'а БЕЗ правки реестра (доменная разметка Task 1 сохранена):
- TASK_TYPE_KEYWORDS +командные глаголы (проверь/составь/поправь/распиши/...);
порядок ключей: marketing/security ДО analysis для «проверь пдн»→security.
- detectRecommendedNode → two-pass: keyword-домен приоритетнее classification-типа
(Pass 1 keyword, Pass 2 classification fallback).
- MICRO_KEYWORDS +увеличь/уменьши/одну строку/bump.
Accuracy regex-only: 68.3% → 80.0% (type 55%→85%, micro 95%→100%, node 55%).
Node остался 55%: конфликт «feature+домен» в одном промпте (баланс→#62 vs
feature→#19) Layer 1 одним узлом не разрешает — это работа Layer 2 (Sonnet).
Ground truth НЕ переписан ради цифры (отказ от overfit, в отличие от
реверченного 112591a где субагент удалял реестровые keyword'ы).
489/489 tools GREEN.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Snapshot "Commit:" field referenced 30b795c (dangling orphan from
amend cycle). Replaced with actual e239160a + 436284c5 (F1 fix).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Spec review F1: positions 4-5 had stale numbers (#41:2 #42:2);
actual analyzer output shows #25:3, #39:3 (and #53:3 tied at pos 5).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Зафиксированы цифры дисциплины роутера на 2026-05-24 перед запуском
enforcement-хука этапа 3. Sanity-check passed: missed_before=17 ==
missed_after=17 (delta=0) после переключения источника правды на реестр.
observer-classification-map.json помечен deprecated — для удаления в этапе 4.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Auto-generated блок с разбивкой % дисциплины по типам задач,
router-step distribution + suspicious-флаг, boundaries-applied rate.
Backward-compat: блок опускается, если discipline не передан.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Дмитрий