Files
portal/tools
Дмитрий 722f4bb189 fix(router-gate-v4): calibrate per-tool LLM-judge — exempt Skill (calib 1) + test-runners (calib 3)
The Layer-4 per-tool judge over-blocked: it judged every Skill/Edit/Write/
Bash/Task against the declared task and blocked on doubt. A vague prompt
classifies as unknown/ambiguous, so the judge then blocked essentially all
artifact-producing tools — including the prescribed §17 skill entry and the
mandatory TDD test run — making legitimate, owner-mandated work impossible
and blocking its own fix (3 reproduced blocks this session).

Calibration 1 (scope fix, NOT a discipline drop): remove `Skill` from
MUTATING_TOOLS in tools/llm-judge-per-tool.mjs. Invoking a skill mutates no
state and is the §17-mandated entry into work; the real mutations it leads to
(Edit/Write/MultiEdit/Bash/PowerShell/Task/commit/push) stay fully judged.

Calibration 3 (scope fix, NOT a discipline drop): add isTestRunnerBashEvent to
tools/enforce-llm-judge-per-tool.mjs and skip it in runPerTool, mirroring the
existing readonly-Bash exemption. A test run (vitest/pest/phpunit/php artisan
test/composer test/npm test) only inspects + reports and is a mandatory TDD
step; commands chaining to a mutation (&& ; | backtick $() are NOT exempt.

doubt→block on real mutations against a known task is unchanged (covered by the
"mutating Bash (git commit) STILL judged" test). Calibration 2 (allow on
unknown task) was rejected by the owner as a discipline hole and not added.

Regression: vitest tools-only 1945 passed | 2 skipped (+18 calibration tests).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-05-31 10:04:43 +03:00
..