Машина 3-C «Машина охвата A/B/C/D» собрана (TDD): coverage-machine.mjs —
A граф зависимостей (buildDependencyGraph/topoOrder/findHoles/decompositionGroups),
B реестр нужды↔решения (coverageRegistry: дыры+сироты), C requestsChecklist,
D ограничения как нужды (effectiveNeeds), хребет readinessChecklist (4 галочки + §).
Независимый верификатор охвата (рычаг E §6.3). 19 новых тестов, регрессия 2158 GREEN.
Сверка 2026-06-04: все 26 назначений «пункт → машина» актуальны и
непротиворечивы (собранное в M2 подтверждено по коду). Внесены 6 пометок
дельты, назначения по машинам не менялись:
- п.15: default-deny уточнён зелёным проходом (finding 9) + узкое Write-
исключение K4 (Вариант А, реализуется в 3-D)
- п.23: D29 как отдельный сверщик растворён → роль у артефакта + закрытой
двери (C-7); якорь «сырая просьба» сохранён в P16-e (M3)
- п.24: добавлен контракт K5 (судья судит план как будущее, «проверено» за
факт не берёт; реальное проверено = рантайм-сентинел M5)
- п.26: routing-tag ещё живой, редизайн escape отложен в M6
- мастер-карта: K5 добавлен в аварийный блок Машины 4 (рядом с K1/K2)
- чертёж M2: условие В синхронизировано с каноном K4 (читаемый .md через
узкое исключение; печать seal — только каналом одобрения)
Стоит на фундаменте Машины 1. 9 задач: freeze/seal плана (HMAC), детерминированный
матч действие-шаг (op+object, без LLM), персист, семена D12/D13, default-deny decide,
runGate+fail-CLOSED, авто-аудит дверей P15-b, сверка план-след P25-d, инварианты.
Проектные решения A-G помечены явно для ревью владельцем.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Дизайн «роутер-наставник» (brainstorm-стадия, не канон):
- Полный граф+каталог узлов 100% роутеру и судье (отменено код-сужение; кэш, обновление на добавление узла в 4 местах)
- Риск-фильтр у роутера (бывш. W1+W2): тройка где-сломается/больно/откатимо, чинит сам, без блока
- Судья B (вход) / C (граница по обратимости) / D (Sonnet на воротах + код-сверка на исполнении)
- Качество плана и скилов = мерило + совет; дисциплина судьи; H (реакция владельца)
- Дыры I-1..I-4 + 3 призрака разобраны (I-2 закрыт, остальное аут/остаток)
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 noreply@anthropic.com
Sibling Claude session 2026-05-30 found that lastTurnEntries treats
harness-injected skill bodies as spurious turn boundaries, breaking both
enforce-memory-coverage (can't find user's coverage line) AND
enforce-normative-content-rules::detectLegitSkillActive (can't find the
Skill tool_use that lives in the assistant message BEFORE the body).
Refinement applied here: this session inspected 29 isMeta:true entries
across the live transcript (8f4ba767-...jsonl) via a debug helper and
found isMeta:true is ALSO used for "Continue from where you left off"
auto-resume, Stop hook feedback strings, and <local-command-caveat>
wrappers — those are real user-equivalent boundaries that must remain
visible. Sibling's blanket "skip isMeta" proposal would have broken them.
Discriminator: skip ONLY when isMeta === true AND typeof sourceToolUseID
=== 'string' (tool-spawned content). Skill bodies have the linking field;
the other isMeta sources do not. The sourceToolUseID field is harness-
controlled and not writable by controller from inside a tool call —
cannot be spoofed.
Behaviour after fix:
* Skill body injection → skipped → walk continues back to find user's
real prompt (with coverage line).
* The assistant message containing the Skill tool_use is now inside the
turn → detectLegitSkillActive finds it → normative writes pass when
invoked under an active claude-md-management skill.
* "Continue from where you left off." → still treated as turn boundary.
* Stop hook feedback strings → still treated as turn boundary.
TDD:
* 3 new tests in tools/enforce-hook-helpers.test.mjs under the
"lastTurnEntries / lastUserPromptText / lastAssistantText / turnToolUses"
describe block:
- lastTurnEntries skips skill body injections (isMeta + sourceToolUseID)
- lastTurnEntries does NOT skip "Continue from where you left off"
(isMeta but no sourceToolUseID)
- turnToolUses includes Skill tool_use spawned in same turn as the
injected skill body
* 2/3 RED→GREEN (the "Continue" negative test passed on baseline already
since its string content satisfies the existing string-content branch).
Scope:
* Fixes 2 of the 5 structural quirks documented in the Stream H
completion log (enforce-memory-coverage gap, enforce-normative-
content-rules detectLegitSkillActive gap).
* Does NOT fix: enforce-read-path-deny LEGIT_SKILLS exemption gap
(separate hook, no lastTurnEntries dependency); TDD-gate cross-actor
blindness (different mechanism — actor session boundaries);
detectFullTestRun regex narrowness (command-pattern matching).
Regression: vitest tools 1788/1788 GREEN (was 1785; +3 new tests).
Plan: docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-30-lastturnentries-skill-body-skip.md
Closes Stream H completely. Appends a "Final activation — Layer 4 verified
live" section to the completion log documenting:
- User completed Action 2 (.claude/settings.json batch replacement) via
.scratch/activate-stream-h.ps1 on 2026-05-30 ~12:38 МСК. Backup at
.claude/settings.json.backup-20260530-123741. 7 new hook entries appended.
- User completed Action 1 (keytar install + ROUTER_LLM_KEY in user env)
with --legacy-peer-deps to resolve the histoire/vite peer conflict
(memory quirk 74). ROUTER_LLM_KEY (35 chars) exported user-level. Base
URL left at Anthropic default — no ProxyAPI middleware.
- Live verification via .scratch/verify-layer-4.ps1 → both opt-in
integration tests under ROUTER_LLM_LIVE_TEST=1 PASS on real API calls:
* single Sonnet judge returns a parseable YES/NO — 1950 ms
* 3-judge consensus reaches all three models with real (non-null)
verdicts — 2021 ms (Sonnet 4.6 + Haiku 4.5 + Opus 4.7 each returned
a real YES/NO; no fallback to doubt)
Total duration 4.54 s. 4 real API calls. Cost ~$0.01-0.05.
Layer 4 LLM-judge now active on live traffic. Router-gate v4 reaches the
master-plan target ~0.5-0.8% bypass rate. Architectural floor ~0.5%
irreducible per the 7 fundamental limits documented in memory
`feedback_asymptote_floor_irreducible.md`.
Carry-over: PowerShell 5.1 mojibake on em-dashes inside .scratch/ helper
scripts is cosmetic only; affects the final summary banner, not the
verification itself. Non-blocking.
Docs-only change; covered by docs-only short-circuit in
enforce-verify-before-push (§5 п.13 CLAUDE.md).
Stream H closed. No further follow-ups required.
Closes Stream H. Adds the canonical completion artifact at
docs/observer/notes/2026-05-30-stream-h-completion.md documenting:
- All 10 commits landed in this Stream H push (2a3b5b4d..d75c8922 main).
- Per-task summary linking each H<N> to its commit SHA + 1-line rationale.
- Two manual actions the user needs to perform outside Claude to activate
the new hooks: (1) npm install keytar + store ROUTER_LLM_KEY in keychain,
(2) append 7 hook entries to .claude/settings.json (verbatim JSON
provided). Both are blocked from in-Claude execution by structural
router-gate hooks (read-path-deny on settings.json without LEGIT_SKILLS
exemption; npm install in router-gate hard-blacklist).
- 5 defects/quirks discovered during execution with follow-up direction
(read-path-deny skill exemption gap, TDD-gate cross-actor blindness,
detectFullTestRun regex narrowness, findOverride stub, subagent vitest
output misread).
- 5 intentional deferrals listed (H10 worktree bootstrap; full LLM-judge
activation pending Action 1; Smoke 8 live test pending Action 2; no
normative bump because Stream H is infrastructure not Tooling-canon;
worktree cleanup conditional on local presence).
- Cumulative state after Stream H: 1776/1776 vitest tools GREEN, 6 hooks
ready to activate, 2 brain-retro analyzer extensions live, recovery
runbook published with 7 fabrication patterns.
Docs-only change; covered by docs-only short-circuit in
enforce-verify-before-push (§5 п.13 CLAUDE.md).
Stream H Task 11 of 11 — final consolidation.
Дмитрий